Stop Sandwiching your Feedback: Try this Instead
Praise. Criticism. Praise.
It sounds considerate. Start with a compliment, deliver the difficult message, and finish on a positive note.
This is the familiar feedback sandwich. But in trying to make criticism easier to hear, managers can sometimes make the message harder to understand.
Employees may focus on the praise, feel anxious about the criticism, or leave without knowing what needs to change.
So, instead of asking, “How can I make this feedback sound nicer?”, ask:
“How can I make this feedback clear, respectful, and actionable?”
Why the Feedback Sandwich Doesn’t Always Work
The intention is understandable: managers want to protect relationships while addressing performance gaps.
However, when praise is used mainly to soften criticism, the central message can become diluted. Employees may also struggle to distinguish genuine recognition from a lead-in to negative feedback.
Effective feedback isn’t about avoiding discomfort. It’s about making improvement possible.
Try the DESC Model for Workplace Feedback
The DESC model is a framework for assertive communication that helps managers address difficult situations without becoming vague or confrontational.
DESC stands for Describe, Express, Specify, and Consequences.
D – Describe the Behaviour
Focus on observable facts rather than personal judgments.
Instead of “You’re careless,” say:
“You’ve missed the last three sprint deadlines.”
E – Express the Impact
Explain why the behaviour matters.
“This has delayed the team’s work and affected our project timeline.”
S – Specify the Change
Clearly state what needs to happen next.
“Going forward, please flag any deadline risks at least 48 hours in advance.”
C – Explain the Consequences
Connect the requested change to its outcomes.
“Flagging risks early will help us adjust priorities, manage workloads, and protect delivery timelines.”
This structure helps employees understand what happened, why it matters, and how they can respond.
Clear Feedback Is Not Harsh Feedback
Consider the difference:
“You’re unreliable.”
“You missed three deadlines. Let’s identify what’s getting in the way and agree on how you’ll communicate delays earlier.”
The first statement labels the person. The second addresses behaviour and opens a conversation about improvement.
The goal is clarity without hostility.
The DESC model isn’t about removing empathy or making every conversation rigid. Managers should adapt their approach to the situation, listen to the employee’s perspective, and allow space for dialogue.
Your Next Feedback Conversation
Before delivering difficult feedback, ask yourself:
“Am I softening this message because the employee needs it, or because I’m uncomfortable saying it?”
Then use DESC to structure the conversation:
- Describe what happened.
- Express its impact.
- Specify the expected change.
- Explain the consequences of that change.
Use genuine praise when it is deserved, but don’t rely on compliments to disguise the message.
Effective feedback isn’t about making criticism sound pleasant. It’s about helping employees understand expectations, take ownership, and improve performance.
Build Better Feedback Skills with TBH Circle
TBH Circle helps organisations strengthen managerial effectiveness through behavioural science, experiential learning, and practical leadership development interventions—equipping managers to communicate assertively, navigate difficult conversations, and build stronger working relationships.